Skip to main content

Comparison with Liquity V2 (BOLD)

Liquity V2 (BOLD) is another immutable CDP stablecoin on Ethereum. This overview compares the two protocols. Liquity details follow its official borrowing and liquidation documentation and current contracts repository.

What's the same​

  • The trove model. Open a trove with collateral, mint stablecoin debt against it, repay later. ICR, TCR, MCR, CCR mean what they mean in BOLD.
  • Stability Pools per collateral. Each collateral type has its own Stability Pool. Depositors absorb liquidations on that pool's branch.
  • Liquidation paths. Offset against the Stability Pool first; redistribute to remaining troves on the same branch if the Pool can't cover.
  • Per-branch trove organization. Ordered for cheap liquidation and redemption walks. (RAI keeps two lists per branch: base and Redemption Shield.)
  • Gas compensation. Both protocols combine a fixed reserve with a collateral-based payment. Liquity V2 uses a refundable 0.0375 WETH reserve plus the lesser of 0.5% of collateral or two collateral-token units; RAI Dollar uses a 200 RD reserve plus 0.5% of collateral.
  • Hint helpers. Position-changing operations take upperHint/lowerHint for cheap inserts. (Front ends compute these for you.)

What's different​

Liquity V2 (BOLD)RAI Dollar
Borrower rateUser-set per trove. Each borrower chooses an interest rate and can manage it directly or delegate management. Higher-rate troves sit farther back in the redemption order.Adaptive, automated. One system rate is set by the controller, with a branch-utilization adjustment added on top. There is no per-trove rate-setting decision.
Redemption protectionNo borrower-selected guarantee. A higher rate moves a trove back in the queue, and a branch with enough Stability Pool BOLD to cover its debt receives no normal-redemption allocation, but either condition can change.Optional shield. Borrowers pay a surcharge to make their trove ineligible for normal-mode redemption. The protection ends during branch shutdown.
Collateral typesETH (WETH internally), wstETH, rETHSeven branches: WETH, wstETH, WBTC, rETH, weETH, tBTC, PAXG.
Branch stress modeSafety Mode. When branch TCR falls below CCR, pure collateral withdrawals and pure BOLD draws are blocked.Recovery mode. Any adjustment that lowers a trove's ICR is blocked. A paired adjustment is allowed only if it does not lower ICR and satisfies the final MCR/CCR checks.
Stability deposit yieldLiquidation collateral + BOLD yield. When a depositor touches the position, BOLD yield can be claimed or added to the deposit and collateral gains can be claimed or stashed.Liquidation collateral + RD inflows folded into deposit balances: a PI-controlled share of branch interest grows deposits on each drip. Depositors also accrue MOAI emissions.
LP rewardsNo token emissions. 25% of borrow interest is set aside as protocol-incentivized liquidity, and LQTY stakers vote each epoch on which initiatives (e.g. LP incentives) receive it.Automated. LP stakers earn MOAI emissions on a fixed schedule (split equally between the RD/USDC and RD/USDT pools) plus RD fee inflows whose share is PI-controlled by live LP utilization. No vote required.
Undercollateralized debtResidual branch bad debt can persist. Liquity governance can redirect BOLD interest toward burning it, but immutable core contracts do not automatically repay it.Automated, layered repayment. When a shut-down branch is left with debt after its collateral is gone, the Aggregator routes a 0.5% slice of healthy-branch redemptions, the normal branch redemption fee in RD, and 50% of the MOAI-staker allocation toward payDebt. Repayment speed depends on future redemption and fee volume.
Collateral that can blacklistThe current collateral set avoids issuer-blacklistable assets.Explicit failure handling. On WBTC, weETH, and PAXG branches, failed transfer probes allow permissionless shutdown, removing the branch from multi-branch redemption and new issuance. If the token issuer has actually frozen a pool, however, that collateral may still be unable to leave it.
Governance tokenLQTY (V2). Stakers vote to direct the protocol-incentivized-liquidity share of borrow interest to initiatives.MOAI. Fee revenue is routed by automated PI controllers that target Stability Pool and LP utilization; the remainder goes to MOAI stakers in RD. No voting required.
Protocol-token stakingLQTY staking supports initiative voting under Liquity's governance system.Three lockup tiers: 7d / 30d / 60d at 1.00× / 1.15× / 1.50× reward multipliers (while the lock is active). Stakers earn RD; there is no voting.
Emissions curveBOLD has no protocol-level emissions. For reference, Liquity V1's LQTY issuance was a 1-year-half-life exponential decay, which is extremely front-loaded: roughly 50% of all LQTY in year one, then halving each year forever (asymptotic cap).Front-loaded, peaks at month 12, terminates within its 48-month window. ~681k MOAI/month per program (SP and LP) at launch, climbing to ~1.17M MOAI/month at month 12, then declining to the full 31.5M-per-program cap at month 47. Immutable. Full schedule: MOAI emissions schedule.

The two emission philosophies side by side — RAI Dollar's ramp-and-terminate schedule (solid) against a 1-year half-life decay at the same cap (dashed):

Redemption protection in practice​

In BOLD, normal redemptions are ordered by borrower-selected interest rate. A higher rate moves a trove farther back in the queue, and borrowers can manage the rate directly or delegate it. A branch can also receive no normal-redemption allocation while its Stability Pool covers all branch debt. Neither form is a borrower-selected guarantee, because rates, debt, and Stability Pool coverage can change.

In RAI Dollar, Redemption Shield is an explicit on-chain choice. A trove with the shield enabled is excluded from normal-mode redemption, regardless of its ICR or rate. The setting can change at most once per 24 hours and carries a variable surcharge. If the branch shuts down, the protection ends and shutdown redemption can reach both cohorts.

Fee pipeline and emissions​

BOLD has no protocol-token emission schedule. Liquity allocates 25% of borrow interest to protocol-incentivized liquidity, and LQTY stakers vote on which initiatives receive it.

RAI Dollar's pipeline is fully automated:

  1. Per-branch FeeRouter splits borrow interest between the local Stability Pool and the cross-branch GlobalFeeRouter. Split is PI-controlled by SP utilization (target 25%, bounds 10–60% at launch, with the floor rising to 35% as MOAI emissions taper).
  2. GlobalFeeRouter also receives the 0.25% redemption protocol fee and early-repayment fees. It tops up keeper rewards, then splits between LP staking and MOAI staking, again PI-controlled, by LP utilization (target 12.5%, bounds 10–60% at launch, with the floor rising to 35% as MOAI emissions taper). If a shut-down branch is left with bad debt and MOAI is staked, UNDERCOLLATERALIZED_FRAC = 50% of the MOAI-staker share is diverted to pay it down; the LP share is unaffected.

Result: MOAI stakers receive their share of protocol fees in RD continuously, without any vote or claim window. LP stakers receive both MOAI emissions and RD fee inflows. Fee shares are set by the controllers' allocation, not by governance. (Branch redemption fees do not flow to stakers; they are retained by the redeemed trove, or in the bad-debt-sink case routed to that branch's payDebt. See Fees.)

In RAI Dollar, staking MOAI is sufficient to receive the staker share of fees, and MOAI emissions to Stability Pool depositors and LP stakers follow a fixed schedule. There is no on-chain governance vote.

Stability and the peg​

BOLD's peg model relies on redemption arbitrage and on whatever rate the market is willing to pay individual troves. RD adds two more mechanisms:

  • An adaptive system rate set by a PI controller on the RD/USD market price (BOLD has no analogous system-wide controller; rates are individual).
  • An internal price called par that the controller can adjust within $0.75–$1.30 under sustained stress, widening the redemption-arbitrage spread to help drive market RD back to $1. Par is normally exactly $1.00.

See How RD stays near $1 for the overview and Peg control for the controller details.